Skip to content
The Everyday Cinephile Logo

The Everyday Cinephile

Celebrating the everyday entertainment of early cinema

Primary Menu
  • Articles
  • Reviews
    • Book Reviews
    • Film Reviews
  • Blog Series
    • Top 100 Silent Movies
    • European Silent Cinema Project
    • Utah on Film
  • Blogathons
  • About
  • Home
  • Reviews
  • Page 7

Reviews

Reviews of film and books

The Sound of Fury (1950) — A Blacklisted Film Noir TheSoundofFury-1950
  • Film Reviews

The Sound of Fury (1950) — A Blacklisted Film Noir

Shawn Hall May 10, 2020 0

The Hollywood Blacklist in the 1950s really cut short a lot of interesting careers and forced...

Read More Read more about The Sound of Fury (1950) — A Blacklisted Film Noir
The Ten Commandments (1923): DeMille’s Silent Biblical Epic
  • Film Reviews

The Ten Commandments (1923): DeMille’s Silent Biblical Epic

Shawn Hall April 5, 2020 2
So let it be reviewed, so let it be watched! Read the whole post...
Read More Read more about The Ten Commandments (1923): DeMille’s Silent Biblical Epic

Posts pagination

Previous 1 … 4 5 6 7

Latest Posts

  • Seeing Double: Special Effects and Dual Roles in Silent Film

    Seeing Double: Special Effects and Dual Roles in Silent Film

    6 days ago
    Today, we don’t blink an eye when we see a man flying …
  • Buster Keaton Silent Shorts—RANKED

    Buster Keaton Silent Shorts—RANKED

    2 months ago
    After his 14-film screen partnership with Roscoe Arbuckle, Buster Keaton took over …
  • Silent Movie Day Program: The History of Silent Comedy

    Silent Movie Day Program: The History of Silent Comedy

    2 months ago
    I’m trying something different to celebrate Silent Movie Day this year. I’ve …
  • The Silent Movie Day Blogathon

    The Silent Movie Day Blogathon

    2 months ago
    For the sixth Silent Movie Day (that’s today!) me and Silentology‘s Lea …
  • Happy Silent Movie Month!

    Happy Silent Movie Month!

    2 months ago
    With Silent Movie Day on September 29th, I’ve been celebrating this whole …

Proud CMBA Member

Classic Movie Blog Association Logo
Buster Keaton's silent film comedy still feels modern more than a century later. This essay compares Buster Keaton, Charlie Chaplin, and Harold Lloyd to show how Keaton's deadpan response to an unpredictable, mechanical world with surreal gags, practical stunts, and accidental success still resonates today.

Explore More Buster Keaton:

Read my rankings and reviews of his 19 solo silent shorts:
https://theeverydaycinephile.com/reviews/film-reviews/buster-keaton-silent-shorts-ranked/

Watch Next:

Seven Types of Lost Silent Film:
https://youtu.be/aTkc1UUhv2g

Buster Keaton silent shorts playlist:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLZ1eYMbBjaqs

Chapters:

0:00 Why Buster Keaton's Comedy Is Still Modern
1:40 Chaplin, Lloyd & Keaton: Three Comic Worldviews
2:57 Buster and the Unpredictable Universe
5:47 Surrealism and Cartoon Gags
6:55 How Romance Disrupts Keaton's World
11:15 MGM and Keaton's Changing Comedy
12:50 The Great Stone Face and Modern Life

Sources and further reading:

Walter Kerr, The Silent Clowns (1975)

James L. Neibaur and Terri Niemi, Buster Keaton's Silent Shorts: 1920–1923 (2013)

Buster Keaton interview with Studs Terkel, September 5, 1960

Buster Keaton: The Shorts Collection 1917–1923 (Kino Lorber / Lobster Films, Blu-ray)

Kevin Brownlow and David Gill, Buster Keaton: A Hard Act to Follow (1987)


Films featured in order of appearance:

The Kid (1921) | Cops (1922)
One Week (1920) | For Heaven's Sake (1926)
Moonshine (1918) | The General (1926)
Easy Street (1917) | The Pilgrim (1923)
The Scarecrow (1920) | My Wife's Relations (1922)
The Playhouse (1921) | The Blacksmith (1922)
The High Sign (1921) | Three Ages (1923)
Our Hospitality (1923) | Go West (1925)
College (1927) | Spite Marriage (1929)
What! No Beer? (1933) | Safety Last! (1923)
Steamboat Bill, Jr. (1928) | The Electric House (1922)
Daydreams (1922) | Sherlock Jr. (1924)
The Gold Rush (1925) | Ask Father (1919)
The Goat (1921) | Neighbors (1920)
The Balloonatic (1923) | Convict 13 (1920)
The Frozen North (1922) | Seven Chances (1925)
The Navigator (1924) | Battling Butler (1926)
The Cameraman (1928) | Speak Easily (1932)
Hard Luck (1921) | The Boat (1921)

Connect:

Blog: https://theeverydaycinephile.com/
Letterboxd: https://letterboxd.com/silentshawn95/
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@silentshawn95
Bluesky: https://bsky.app/profile/silentshawn95.bsky.social

About this channel:

The Everyday Cinephile explores silent cinema and film history through reviews and video essays about why classic movies still matter, from Buster Keaton and silent comedy to film preservation and overlooked films.

#BusterKeaton #SilentFilm #FilmHistory

Music credits:

"Comedy - Comedy Music" – MaksymMalko:
https://pixabay.com/music/comedy-comedy-comedy-music-581018/

"Crying" – Music_For_Videos:
https://pixabay.com/music/solo-piano-crying-164238/

"Silent Movie Standard Version" – Music_For_Videos:
https://pixabay.com/music/bloopers-silent-movie-standard-version-164256/

"Silent Film Piano" – Pilot2Kid:
https://pixabay.com/music/traditional-jazz-silent-film-piano-346956/

"Comedy - Comedy Music" – Tatamusic:
https://pixabay.com/music/comedy-comedy-comedy-music-590375/

"Comedy - Comedy Music" – The_Mountain:
https://pixabay.com/music/comedy-comedy-comedy-music-490001/

"Lounge Piano" – WaveMaster:
https://pixabay.com/music/traditional-jazz-lounge-piano-170682/

"Lazy Days - Tired" – geoffharvey:
https://pixabay.com/music/acoustic-group-lazy-days-tired-385888/

"Galante (Minueto)" from 12 Danzas españolas – Enrique Granados, arrangement: Hiroshi Munekawa, recording: Gregor Quendel / Classicals.de (CC BY-NC 4.0):
https://www.classicals.de/granados-12-spanish-dances

"Sunday Smooth" by Scott Buckley, CC BY 4.0:
https://www.scottbuckley.com.au/library/sunday-smooth/
Why Buster Keaton's Comedy Feels So Modern
Keaton’s first foray into feature filmmaking gives us mixed results but show plenty of flashes to the heights he’d reach in the upcoming years in silent comedy.

#busterkeaton #threeages #silentcomedy #1923 #silentfilm
THREE AGES (1923)—Buster a Keaton’s First Comedy
And we’ve reached the end! Buster Keaton tries to sail away from his heartbreak in THE LOVE NEST, only to end up aboard a ship commanded by a captain who has a rather extreme approach to dealing with crew members who disappoint him.

THE LOVE NEST brings us to the end of Buster Keaton’s short comedies just in time for Silent Movie Day on September 29. Thanks for following along—and next up, it’s time to start working through Buster’s silent feature comedies!

#busterkeaton #thelovenest #silentcomedy #silentfilm #silentmovieday
THE LOVE NEST (1923)—Buster Keaton's Shorts (33/33)
Subscribe

Letterboxd Reviews

  • The Student of Prague, 1913 - ★★★
    While the film has a handful of interesting compositions and plays with foreground and background to frame its actors and action, the film is severely […]
  • The Bell Boy, 1918 - ★★★★
    This is the first collaboration where Keaton really feels like an actual comedy partner with Arbuckle, getting several jokes that are just Keaton on his […]
  • Out West, 1918 - ★★★★
    One of my favorite Arbuckle-Keaton comedies. I especially love the macabre gags, like when Keaton's saloon owner finds a man cheating at cards, shoots him […]
  • The Devil-Doll, 1936 - ★★★½
    I love how nonsensical this is. Barrymore, so hell-bent on revenge after escaping jail, throws all morality and logic out the window and uses his […]
  • The Guardsman, 1931 - ★★
    The plot is very screwball, but it has none of the comedy. The disguise the husband wears is so ludicrous all believability is lost when […]

1910s (23) 1920s (46) 1930s (10) 1940s (5) 1950s (6) Auteurs (13) Biographies (8) Blogathons (18) Buster Keaton (7) Cecil B. DeMille (7) Early Cinema (11) European Cinema (20) Film Recommendations (6) German Expressionism (4) Homepage Featured (13) Horror (5) Literary Adaptations (11) Lost Films (7) Mormons in the Movies (10) Pordenone Silent Film Festival (6) Pre-1910 (13) Pre-Code Hollywood (8) Silent Comedy (14) Silent Movies (89) Utah and the Movies (12) Utahns in Film (6) Westerns (6) Women Filmmakers (6) YouTube (4) Zane Grey (5)

You may have missed

BusterKeaton-ThePlayhouse1922-Dance
  • Articles
  • Blogathons

Seeing Double: Special Effects and Dual Roles in Silent Film

Shawn Hall November 13, 2026 3
31-DayDreams
  • Blogathons
  • Film Reviews

Buster Keaton Silent Shorts—RANKED

Shawn Hall September 29, 2026 5
Silent Movie Day Blogathon Banner with Mabel Normand.
  • Blogathons

Silent Movie Day Program: The History of Silent Comedy

Shawn Hall September 29, 2026 0
Silent Movie Day Blogathon Banner with Western style poster.
  • Blogathons

The Silent Movie Day Blogathon

Shawn Hall September 28, 2026 5

Follow Me on My Socials

Bluesky TikTok YouTube Letterboxd Letterboxd

Questions, recommendations, or collaboration inquiries?

Contact Me
© 2020-2026 by Shawn Hall and The Everyday Cinephile. All rights reserved. No content on this website may be reproduced without written permission from the author. | MoreNews by AF themes.